Data period: games from 1 Oct 2025 – 30 Sep 2026 (sample of the Lichess open database) · Page updated: 13 Nov 2026
50.6%
Black's score at Lichess rating 1200–1499 · 59,857 games, Oct 2025–Sep 2026 sample
Black scores 50.6% at 1200–1499 and 48.1% at 2100+. An observed change in our sample, not a verdict.
At your level
At Under 1200, White scored 49.6% in 31,493 Caro-Kann Defense games (±0.5, approximate).At 1200–1499, White scored 49.4% in 59,857 Caro-Kann Defense games (±0.4, approximate).At 1500–1799, White scored 49.8% in 86,546 Caro-Kann Defense games (±0.3, approximate).At 1800–2099, White scored 50.8% in 76,784 Caro-Kann Defense games (±0.3, approximate).At 2100+, White scored 51.9% in 38,423 Caro-Kann Defense games (±0.5, approximate).
Position after 1.e4 c6. 293,103 games in this sample reached it.
At 1500–1799 (Lichess rating), Black scored 50.2% in 86,546 Caro-Kann Defense games (±0.3; games from Oct 2025–Sep 2026).
Black won 48.2% of them, White won 47.9%, and 3.9% were drawn.
No clear difference from 50% at this level (inside the margin)
In games from Oct 2025–Sep 2026, Black scored 50.2% (±0.3) with the Caro-Kann Defense in sampled Lichess games at the 1500–1799 Lichess rating level (86,546 games). Observed results, not causation.
At a glance
In this sample, White's score ranged from 49.4% (1200–1499) to 51.9% (2100+).
Treat this spread with caution: the margins are approximate (see How it works).
It appeared most often in the 1800–2099 group (5.8% of that group's games).
Draws were most common in the 2100+ group (5.8%).
These are observed results for the selected games (rated, players within 200 rating points of each other). They describe what happened — they do not prove the opening caused the result.
Results by Lichess rating level
Each row shows how the Caro-Kann Defense games at one rating level ended: White wins, draws and Black wins, across all time controls combined. Rating level is the average Lichess rating of both players.
White won drawn Black won. Caro-Kann Defense — results by Lichess rating level, all time controls combined (minimum 300 games per row).
Under 120031,493 games
White wins 48.1% · draws 3.1% · Black wins 48.9% · White's score 49.6%±0.5 · how common 3.9%
1200–149959,857 gamesIn the headline
White wins 47.9% · draws 3.1% · Black wins 49.0% · White's score 49.4%±0.4 · how common 5.0%
1500–179986,546 games
White wins 47.9% · draws 3.9% · Black wins 48.2% · White's score 49.8%±0.3 · how common 5.4%
1800–209976,784 games
White wins 48.5% · draws 4.5% · Black wins 47.0% · White's score 50.8%±0.3 · how common 5.8%
2100+38,423 gamesCompared with
White wins 49.0% · draws 5.8% · Black wins 45.2% · White's score 51.9%±0.5 · how common 5.6%
"White's score" = wins + half of draws. "±" is an approximate 95% margin based only on the number of games. It does not cover sampling bias or related games (the same players appear many times), so real uncertainty is larger. "How common" = share of all sampled games at that level that reached this position. Ratings are Lichess ratings; they are not interchangeable with Chess.com or FIDE ratings.
Results by time control
Each row shows how the Caro-Kann Defense games ended in one Lichess time control, across all rating levels combined.
Caro-Kann Defense — results by time control, all rating levels combined (minimum 300 games per row)
Time control
Games
White wins
Draws
Black wins
White's score
Bullet
106,283
48.8%
3.0%
48.2%
50.3%
Blitz
138,155
48.1%
4.5%
47.4%
50.3%
Rapid
47,200
47.5%
5.0%
47.5%
50.0%
Classical
1,465
42.5%
5.9%
51.6%
45.5%
This table and the rating rows are separate summaries: rating levels are not split by time control here, and time controls are not split by rating. Observed results only; approximate uncertainty applies as above.
Guess first
At Under 1200, in what share of Caro-Kann Defense games does White answer 2.Nf3?At 1200–1499, in what share of Caro-Kann Defense games does White answer 2.Nf3?At 1500–1799, in what share of Caro-Kann Defense games does White answer 2.Nf3?At 1800–2099, in what share of Caro-Kann Defense games does White answer 2.Nf3?At 2100+, in what share of Caro-Kann Defense games does White answer 2.Nf3?
You?
Real33.9%33.8%30.7%24.7%19.3%
Move the slider, then press Lock in. Or skip: the answer is also in the replies table below.
The real number is 33.9% (10,653 of 31,414 games at Under 1200 in which White made the next move).The real number is 33.8% (20,221 of 59,778 games at 1200–1499 in which White made the next move).The real number is 30.7% (26,584 of 86,466 games at 1500–1799 in which White made the next move).The real number is 24.7% (18,931 of 76,743 games at 1800–2099 in which White made the next move).The real number is 19.3% (7,397 of 38,413 games at 2100+ in which White made the next move).
Lowest: 19.3% at 2100+. Highest: 33.9% at Under 1200.Lowest: 19.3% at 2100+. Highest: 33.9% at Under 1200.Lowest: 19.3% at 2100+. Highest: 33.9% at Under 1200.Lowest: 19.3% at 2100+. Highest: 33.9% at Under 1200.Lowest: 19.3% at 2100+. Highest: 33.9% at Under 1200.
Most played replies for White at each level
Top replies with at least 150 games. "Score" is White's score after that reply (wins + half of draws). These comparisons alone can't show that one reply is reliably better — the margins are approximate and stronger or weaker players may prefer different replies.
Replies to 1.e4 c6 by Lichess rating level, all time controls combined
Each row is a separate page with its own games. A difference smaller than the two margins combined is no clear difference. Observed results, not causation.
Deeper positions with this name
The free opening list gives the name Caro-Kann Defense to 6 deeper positions on this line as well. This page counts the first one; games in the 12-month sample that reached each deeper one:
1.e4 c6 2.d4: 130,290 games
1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5: 123,293 games
1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.Nc3: 32,030 games
1.e4 c6 2.Nc3: 28,291 games
1.e4 c6 2.Nc3 d5: 26,505 games
Quick duel
Compare openings at your levelCompare openings at your levelWhich scored higher for Black at 1500–1799?Compare openings at your levelCompare openings at your level
At Under 1200: the Caro-Kann Defense 50.4% and the Sicilian Defense 50.9% for Black (31,493 and 36,542 games). Too close to call: 0.5 points apart, and these game counts need 1.2 points or more.
At 1200–1499: the Caro-Kann Defense 50.6% and the Sicilian Defense 50.2% for Black (59,857 and 86,311 games). Too close to call: 0.4 points apart, and these game counts need 0.8 points or more.
At 1500–1799, the Caro-Kann Defense scored higher for Black: 50.2% in 86,546 games, against 49.5% for the Sicilian Defense in 157,898 games.
0.7 points apart. With these game counts, a gap counts as clear from 0.6 points; it also holds in both halves of the data period.
At 1800–2099: the Caro-Kann Defense 49.2% and the Sicilian Defense 48.9% for Black (76,784 and 162,750 games). Too close to call: 0.3 points apart, and these game counts need 0.7 points or more.
At 2100+: the Caro-Kann Defense 48.1% and the Sicilian Defense 48.5% for Black (38,423 and 85,888 games). Too close to call: 0.4 points apart, and these game counts need 0.9 points or more.
The Caro-Kann Defense against another opening for the same side, at the picked level. A duel is asked only when the gap is clear for the number of games (at least 300 games each, and a gap about three times the usual chance wobble or more, in the same order in both halves of the data period); otherwise the Caro-Kann Defense is compared with the opening closest to that rule, and the reason is named.
The Caro-Kann Defense explained
The Caro-Kann Defense is the opening 1.e4 c6: Black answers White's first move with the c-pawn.[1] This quiet pawn move prepares 2...d5 on the next turn, and if White then captures on d5, Black can take back with the c-pawn.[2][3][4] In our sample of rated Lichess games from Oct 2025–Sep 2026, 293,103 games reached this position.[5]
Position after 1.e4 c6; White to move.
What Black aims for
Unlike the French Defense, which starts 1.e4 e6, the move 1...c6 does not block the diagonal of Black's light-squared bishop, so after 2...d5 the bishop can often come out to f5 or g4.[2][3][4] The price is time: if Black later wants the c-pawn on c5, it needs a second move to get there.[2][3][4]
The main lines after 1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5
Here White can advance the e-pawn, exchange it on d5, or defend it with a knight from c3 or d2.[4] In our sample, 3.e5 was White's most played move in this position: 37.6% of the games with a recorded next move.[5]
White's most played moves after 1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5, all rating levels (123,251 games with a recorded next move)
Share = games with that move ÷ games with a recorded next move. "Games that reached the position" also counts games that got there by another move order. "–" = not counted: our tables count only the positions of the free opening list. Observed choices, not advice.
Wikipedia and the Modern Chess guide call 3.f3 the Fantasy Variation; the free opening list we use names it the Maróczy Variation.[1][3][4] With 3.f3, White is ready to answer 3...dxe4 by taking back on e4 with the f-pawn, keeping two pawns in the centre.[3][4]
Advance Variation: 1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.e5
In the Advance Variation, White pushes the e-pawn to e5 on move three.[1][4] The pawn on e5 gains space and fixes the pawns in the centre.[4][6][7]
Position after 1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.e5; Black to move.
Caro-Kann Defense: Advance Variation (1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.e5, B12): 47,693 games from Oct 2025–Sep 2026, by Lichess rating level, all time controls combined (minimum 300 games per row)
Rating level
Games
White wins
Draws
Black wins
White's score
Under 1200
5,102
49.1%
2.5%
48.3%
50.4% ±1.4
1200–1499
11,047
47.9%
3.4%
48.8%
49.5% ±0.9
1500–1799
14,438
48.1%
3.9%
48.0%
50.0% ±0.8
1800–2099
11,462
48.9%
4.4%
46.7%
51.1% ±0.9
2100+
5,644
50.8%
6.1%
43.1%
53.8% ±1.3
Most played next moves for Black, all levels: 3...Bf5 58.6% (27,949) · 3...c5 30.3% (14,424) · 3...e6 6.1% (2,928), of 47,671 games with a recorded next move (moves with at least 150 games).
4,678 of these games (9.8%) reached the position by a different move order.
"White's score" = wins + half of draws; "±" is an approximate 95% margin. Observed results, not causation.
3...Bf5 was Black's most played answer in our sample, chosen in 58.6% of the games with a recorded next move.[5] Black brings the light-squared bishop out first, so the e-pawn can later go to e6 without shutting the bishop in, as happens in the Advance Variation of the French Defense.[6][7] Black's usual plan is to strike at the base of White's pawn chain on d4 with the c-pawn.[6][7] The immediate 3...c5 makes that strike at once; the free opening list calls it the Botvinnik-Carls Defense.[1][6][7] In our sample it was chosen in 30.3% of the games with a recorded next move.[5]
Exchange Variation: 1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.exd5
In the Exchange Variation, White captures on d5 on move three.[1][4] Black took back with the c-pawn, 3...cxd5, in 97.1% of the games in our sample that reached the position after 3.exd5 with a recorded next move.[5]
Position after 1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.exd5; Black to move.
Caro-Kann Defense: Exchange Variation (1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.exd5 cxd5, B13): 39,481 games from Oct 2025–Sep 2026, by Lichess rating level, all time controls combined (minimum 300 games per row)
Rating level
Games
White wins
Draws
Black wins
White's score
Under 1200
2,397
47.9%
3.6%
48.5%
49.7% ±2.0
1200–1499
5,561
48.1%
2.9%
49.0%
49.6% ±1.3
1500–1799
11,095
48.0%
4.4%
47.7%
50.2% ±0.9
1800–2099
13,241
48.4%
5.0%
46.6%
50.9% ±0.8
2100+
7,187
48.4%
6.5%
45.1%
51.7% ±1.1
Most played next moves for White, all levels: 4.Nf3 28.0% (11,061) · 4.c4 20.7% (8,150) · 4.Bd3 20.5% (8,100), of 39,467 games with a recorded next move (moves with at least 150 games).
4,666 of these games (11.8%) reached the position by a different move order.
"White's score" = wins + half of draws; "±" is an approximate 95% margin. Observed results, not causation.
After 3...cxd5 the pawns form a Carlsbad structure with the colours reversed, the structure known from the Queen's Gambit Declined.[4][8]
Panov Attack: 1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.exd5 cxd5 4.c4
The move 4.c4 starts the Panov Attack, also called the Panov-Botvinnik Attack after Vasily Panov and Mikhail Botvinnik.[1][4] White puts pressure on Black's pawn on d5 straight away, and the play often reaches positions where White has an isolated pawn on d4.[4][9] In our sample, 20.7% of the games that reached 1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.exd5 cxd5 with a recorded next move continued with 4.c4.[5]
Caro-Kann Defense: Panov Attack (1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.exd5 cxd5 4.c4, B13): 8,773 games from Oct 2025–Sep 2026, by Lichess rating level, all time controls combined (minimum 300 games per row)
Rating level
Games
White wins
Draws
Black wins
White's score
Under 1200
227
Not enough games in this sample
1200–1499
757
52.8%
2.4%
44.8%
54.0% ±3.5
1500–1799
2,088
51.0%
4.1%
44.9%
53.0% ±2.1
1800–2099
3,429
51.2%
4.0%
44.8%
53.2% ±1.6
2100+
2,272
48.3%
6.4%
45.3%
51.5% ±2.0
Most played next moves for Black, all levels: 4...Nf6 51.7% (4,532) · 4...Nc6 18.2% (1,599) · 4...e6 11.9% (1,042), of 8,772 games with a recorded next move (moves with at least 150 games).
1,175 of these games (13.4%) reached the position by a different move order.
"White's score" = wins + half of draws; "±" is an approximate 95% margin. Observed results, not causation.
Main Line: 1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.Nd2 dxe4 4.Nxe4
White can defend the e-pawn with 3.Nc3 or 3.Nd2; after Black takes on e4 and the knight takes back, both move orders reach the same position, which the free opening list calls the Main Line.[1][4][10][11] In our sample, 83.6% of the games that reached it got there by a different move order than the list's 1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.Nd2 dxe4 4.Nxe4.[5]
Position after 1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.Nd2 dxe4 4.Nxe4; Black to move.
Caro-Kann Defense: Main Line (1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.Nd2 dxe4 4.Nxe4, B15): 25,593 games from Oct 2025–Sep 2026, by Lichess rating level, all time controls combined (minimum 300 games per row)
Rating level
Games
White wins
Draws
Black wins
White's score
Under 1200
1,361
52.5%
3.6%
43.9%
54.3% ±2.6
1200–1499
3,160
50.6%
3.0%
46.4%
52.1% ±1.7
1500–1799
6,104
50.7%
3.9%
45.4%
52.6% ±1.2
1800–2099
8,423
49.3%
4.9%
45.8%
51.7% ±1.0
2100+
6,545
50.2%
6.4%
43.4%
53.4% ±1.2
Most played next moves for Black, all levels: 4...Nf6 51.7% (13,229) · 4...Bf5 36.3% (9,286) · 4...Nd7 7.7% (1,965), of 25,588 games with a recorded next move (moves with at least 150 games).
21,405 of these games (83.6%) reached the position by a different move order.
"White's score" = wins + half of draws; "±" is an approximate 95% margin. Observed results, not causation.
Black's most played fourth move here was 4...Nf6, followed by 4...Bf5 and 4...Nd7.[5]
In the Classical Variation, 4...Bf5 brings the light-squared bishop out and attacks the knight on e4.[4][10][11]
Caro-Kann Defense: Classical Variation (1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.Nd2 dxe4 4.Nxe4 Bf5, B18): 9,286 games from Oct 2025–Sep 2026, by Lichess rating level, all time controls combined (minimum 300 games per row)
Rating level
Games
White wins
Draws
Black wins
White's score
Under 1200
696
51.4%
3.0%
45.5%
52.9% ±3.7
1200–1499
1,544
50.6%
3.3%
46.1%
52.2% ±2.4
1500–1799
2,681
50.5%
3.6%
45.9%
52.3% ±1.9
1800–2099
2,707
48.9%
5.2%
45.9%
51.5% ±1.8
2100+
1,658
49.1%
7.4%
43.5%
52.8% ±2.3
Most played next moves for White, all levels: 5.Ng3 62.0% (5,757) · 5.Ng5 16.9% (1,571) · 5.Bd3 8.7% (811), of 9,283 games with a recorded next move (moves with at least 150 games).
7,946 of these games (85.6%) reached the position by a different move order.
"White's score" = wins + half of draws; "±" is an approximate 95% margin. Observed results, not causation.
The idea of 4...Nd7 is to bring the other knight to f6 next, so that an exchange of knights on that square does not spoil Black's pawns.[4][10] Names differ here: the free opening list calls 4...Nd7 the Karpov Variation, while Wikipedia gives the Steinitz Variation as its main name and the Karpov Variation as one of its other names.[1][4]
Caro-Kann Defense: Karpov Variation (1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.Nd2 dxe4 4.Nxe4 Nd7, B17): 1,965 games from Oct 2025–Sep 2026, by Lichess rating level, all time controls combined
Rating level
Games
Under 1200
31
1200–1499
91
1500–1799
345
1800–2099
812
2100+
686
Below the site's page gate (at least 2,000 games and 300 games at 3 of the rating levels): counts only, no results.
1,593 of these games reached the position by a different move order.
Lines with 1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.Nd2 dxe4 4.Nxe4 Nf6
After 4...Nf6, White can exchange knights on f6, and Black then has to take back with a pawn: 5...exf6 or 5...gxf6.[4][10] The free opening list calls 5...exf6 the Tartakower Variation; Wikipedia gives it as the Korchnoi Variation and also as the Tartakower Variation.[1][4]
Caro-Kann Defense: Tartakower Variation (1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.Nc3 dxe4 4.Nxe4 Nf6 5.Nxf6+ exf6, B15): 6,539 games from Oct 2025–Sep 2026, by Lichess rating level, all time controls combined (minimum 300 games per row)
Rating level
Games
White wins
Draws
Black wins
White's score
Under 1200
213
Not enough games in this sample
1200–1499
600
44.8%
2.8%
52.3%
46.2% ±3.9
1500–1799
1,296
50.1%
4.8%
45.1%
52.5% ±2.7
1800–2099
2,233
48.5%
6.0%
45.5%
51.5% ±2.0
2100+
2,197
49.7%
7.1%
43.1%
53.3% ±2.0
The caption gives the free opening list's move order, with 3.Nc3; the heading's 3.Nd2 reaches the same position after 4...Nf6.[11]
Most played next moves for White, all levels: 6.Nf3 43.8% (2,862) · 6.c3 27.0% (1,768) · 6.Bc4 10.6% (692), of 6,538 games with a recorded next move (moves with at least 150 games).
1,939 of these games (29.7%) reached the position by a different move order.
"White's score" = wins + half of draws; "±" is an approximate 95% margin. Observed results, not causation.
Accelerated Panov Attack: 1.e4 c6 2.c4
White plays 2.c4 in the Accelerated Panov Attack, bringing the c-pawn forward before the d-pawn moves.[12][13][14] After 1.e4 c6 2.c4 d5, White can transpose into the Panov Attack or follow a path of its own.[13][15] Black can also answer with 2...e5, called the Open Variation, which brings a different pawn structure.[12][13][14][15] White can reach 1.e4 c6 2.c4 through the English Opening as well, by playing 1.c4 c6 2.e4.[13][14]
Position after 1.e4 c6 2.c4; Black to move.
Caro-Kann Defense: Accelerated Panov Attack (1.e4 c6 2.c4, B10): 6,921 games from Oct 2025–Sep 2026, by Lichess rating level, all time controls combined (minimum 300 games per row)
Rating level
Games
White wins
Draws
Black wins
White's score
Under 1200
346
50.0%
2.9%
47.1%
51.4% ±5.2
1200–1499
813
53.4%
4.8%
41.8%
55.8% ±3.3
1500–1799
1,838
50.4%
3.3%
46.3%
52.1% ±2.2
1800–2099
2,410
51.3%
5.4%
43.4%
54.0% ±1.9
2100+
1,514
51.7%
5.5%
42.7%
54.5% ±2.4
Most played next moves for Black, all levels: 2...d5 85.0% (5,881) · 2...e6 4.2% (289) · 2...d6 4.1% (285), of 6,920 games with a recorded next move (moves with at least 150 games).
685 of these games (9.9%) reached the position by a different move order.
"White's score" = wins + half of draws; "±" is an approximate 95% margin. Observed results, not causation.
Breyer Variation: 1.e4 c6 2.d3
White plays 2.d3 in the Breyer Variation, moving the d-pawn one square instead of the main-line d4 push.[16][17][18] After 1.e4 c6 2.d3 d5, White more often plays the knight to d2 than to f3.[17][18] With the knight on d2, White can aim for a King's Indian Attack set-up, which does not occupy the centre with a pawn on d4.[18][19]
Position after 1.e4 c6 2.d3; Black to move.
Caro-Kann Defense: Breyer Variation (1.e4 c6 2.d3, B10): 9,460 games from Oct 2025–Sep 2026, by Lichess rating level, all time controls combined (minimum 300 games per row)
Rating level
Games
White wins
Draws
Black wins
White's score
Under 1200
922
48.9%
3.5%
47.6%
50.7% ±3.2
1200–1499
1,897
49.5%
3.6%
46.9%
51.3% ±2.2
1500–1799
2,588
46.7%
4.0%
49.3%
48.7% ±1.9
1800–2099
2,449
47.9%
4.6%
47.6%
50.1% ±1.9
2100+
1,604
50.8%
4.9%
44.3%
53.2% ±2.4
Most played next moves for Black, all levels: 2...d5 91.3% (8,623) · 2...d6 3.4% (320) · 2...e6 1.7% (164), of 9,448 games with a recorded next move (moves with at least 150 games).
788 of these games (8.3%) reached the position by a different move order.
"White's score" = wins + half of draws; "±" is an approximate 95% margin. Observed results, not causation.
Endgame Offer: 1.e4 c6 2.Nf3 d5 3.d3
The name Endgame Offer belongs to the line 1.e4 c6 2.Nf3 d5 3.d3, where White plays 3.d3 on the third move.[20][21] The Endgame Offer transposes to the Breyer Variation: it reaches the same position as 1.e4 c6 2.d3 d5 followed by the knight to f3.[21][22] White's 3.d3 offers Black a queen trade: after 1.e4 c6 2.Nf3 d5 3.d3 dxe4 4.dxe4 Qxd1+ 5.Kxd1 both queens are off the board.[21][22]
Position after 1.e4 c6 2.Nf3 d5 3.d3; Black to move.
Caro-Kann Defense: Endgame Offer (1.e4 c6 2.Nf3 d5 3.d3, B10): 4,606 games from Oct 2025–Sep 2026, by Lichess rating level, all time controls combined (minimum 300 games per row)
Rating level
Games
White wins
Draws
Black wins
White's score
Under 1200
748
46.5%
4.7%
48.8%
48.9% ±3.5
1200–1499
849
50.4%
3.4%
46.2%
52.1% ±3.3
1500–1799
1,129
52.9%
5.3%
41.8%
55.5% ±2.8
1800–2099
1,093
54.2%
4.4%
41.4%
56.4% ±2.9
2100+
787
50.2%
7.2%
42.6%
53.8% ±3.4
Most played next moves for Black, all levels: 3...dxe4 63.2% (2,912) · 3...Bg4 20.6% (950) · 3...Nf6 4.6% (213), of 4,604 games with a recorded next move (moves with at least 150 games).
1,230 of these games (26.7%) reached the position by a different move order.
"White's score" = wins + half of draws; "±" is an approximate 95% margin. Observed results, not causation.
Hillbilly Attack: 1.e4 c6 2.Bc4
The name Hillbilly Attack belongs to the line 1.e4 c6 2.Bc4, where White plays 2.Bc4 on the second move.[23][24] If Black answers with a pawn to d5 and White takes it, Black's c-pawn takes back and attacks the bishop on c4, so White must move the bishop again and falls a tempo behind.[24][25] White can retreat the bishop to b3 on move three, offering the e-pawn as a gambit to try for an attack.[24][25]
Position after 1.e4 c6 2.Bc4; Black to move.
Caro-Kann Defense: Hillbilly Attack (1.e4 c6 2.Bc4, B10): 19,607 games from Oct 2025–Sep 2026, by Lichess rating level, all time controls combined (minimum 300 games per row)
Rating level
Games
White wins
Draws
Black wins
White's score
Under 1200
3,675
44.0%
3.4%
52.6%
45.7% ±1.6
1200–1499
6,029
45.3%
2.8%
51.9%
46.7% ±1.2
1500–1799
6,419
44.4%
3.8%
51.8%
46.3% ±1.2
1800–2099
2,971
45.0%
4.0%
51.0%
47.0% ±1.8
2100+
513
47.2%
3.9%
48.9%
49.1% ±4.2
Most played next moves for Black, all levels: 2...d5 91.0% (17,825) · 2...e6 3.6% (705) · 2...d6 1.9% (378), of 19,592 games with a recorded next move (moves with at least 150 games).
"White's score" = wins + half of draws; "±" is an approximate 95% margin. Observed results, not causation.
Two Knights Attack: 1.e4 c6 2.Nc3 d5 3.Nf3
The name Two Knights Attack belongs to the line 1.e4 c6 2.Nc3 d5 3.Nf3, where White develops a knight to c3 on move two and another to f3 on move three.[26][27] White develops both knights quickly, aiming for a lead in development.[28][29] A bishop move to g4, attacking the knight on f3, is one of Black's two most common answers.[27][29]
Position after 1.e4 c6 2.Nc3 d5 3.Nf3; Black to move.
Caro-Kann Defense: Two Knights Attack (1.e4 c6 2.Nc3 d5 3.Nf3, B10): 15,730 games from Oct 2025–Sep 2026, by Lichess rating level, all time controls combined (minimum 300 games per row)
Rating level
Games
White wins
Draws
Black wins
White's score
Under 1200
1,652
46.7%
2.9%
50.4%
48.2% ±2.4
1200–1499
2,332
48.5%
2.9%
48.6%
50.0% ±2.0
1500–1799
3,631
50.1%
3.7%
46.2%
52.0% ±1.6
1800–2099
4,610
50.3%
4.6%
45.1%
52.6% ±1.4
2100+
3,505
49.1%
5.7%
45.2%
51.9% ±1.6
Most played next moves for Black, all levels: 3...dxe4 57.1% (8,975) · 3...Bg4 20.1% (3,168) · 3...d4 11.0% (1,733), of 15,725 games with a recorded next move (moves with at least 150 games).
9,536 of these games (60.6%) reached the position by a different move order.
"White's score" = wins + half of draws; "±" is an approximate 95% margin. Observed results, not causation.
The name Mindeno Variation belongs to the line 1.e4 c6 2.Nc3 d5 3.Nf3 Bg4, where Black meets the Two Knights Attack with a bishop move to g4.[27][30] Black develops the light-squared bishop with a threat against the knight on f3, and Wikipedia and Modern Chess both treat the move as a logical, viable reply.[28][29]
Position after 1.e4 c6 2.Nc3 d5 3.Nf3 Bg4; White to move.
Caro-Kann Defense: Two Knights Attack, Mindeno Variation (1.e4 c6 2.Nc3 d5 3.Nf3 Bg4, B11): 3,168 games from Oct 2025–Sep 2026, by Lichess rating level, all time controls combined (minimum 300 games per row)
Rating level
Games
White wins
Draws
Black wins
White's score
Under 1200
382
43.7%
2.6%
53.7%
45.0% ±4.9
1200–1499
535
48.6%
1.5%
49.9%
49.3% ±4.2
1500–1799
656
51.2%
3.2%
45.6%
52.8% ±3.8
1800–2099
815
46.9%
3.9%
49.2%
48.8% ±3.4
2100+
780
42.7%
7.2%
50.1%
46.3% ±3.4
Most played next moves for White, all levels: 4.h3 42.8% (1,355) · 4.exd5 24.4% (773) · 4.Be2 17.7% (560), of 3,165 games with a recorded next move (moves with at least 150 games).
2,018 of these games (63.7%) reached the position by a different move order.
"White's score" = wins + half of draws; "±" is an approximate 95% margin. Observed results, not causation.
Wikipedia calls 3...c5 a sharp alternative to 3...Bf5 that avoids the theory of that move, and Wikibooks lists it as Black's second most common choice after 3...Bf5.[31][32] 4.c3 was White's most played answer in our sample, chosen in 49.0% of the games with a recorded next move.[5] After 4.dxc5 Black usually has good chances to win the pawn back later, for example by playing the e-pawn to e6 and taking back on c5 with the bishop.[31][32] A common alternative for White is 4.Nf3, usually answered by taking on d4 with the c-pawn.[31][32]
Position after 1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.e5 c5; White to move.
Caro-Kann Defense: Advance Variation, Botvinnik-Carls Defense (1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.e5 c5, B12): 14,431 games from Oct 2025–Sep 2026, by Lichess rating level, all time controls combined (minimum 300 games per row)
Rating level
Games
White wins
Draws
Black wins
White's score
Under 1200
1,423
44.6%
2.7%
52.8%
45.9% ±2.6
1200–1499
3,479
44.9%
3.3%
51.8%
46.5% ±1.6
1500–1799
4,510
45.7%
3.8%
50.5%
47.6% ±1.4
1800–2099
3,335
47.3%
4.3%
48.4%
49.5% ±1.7
2100+
1,684
48.8%
6.0%
45.2%
51.8% ±2.3
Most played next moves for White, all levels: 4.c3 49.0% (7,069) · 4.Nf3 19.5% (2,814) · 4.dxc5 17.2% (2,486), of 14,426 games with a recorded next move (moves with at least 150 games).
874 of these games (6.1%) reached the position by a different move order.
"White's score" = wins + half of draws; "±" is an approximate 95% margin. Observed results, not causation.
Where the name comes from
The opening carries the names of two players of the nineteenth century, Horatio Caro and Marcus Kann.[3][4][33] An article in the chess magazine Brüderschaft of October 1886, with material by Caro, discussed 1.e4 c6, and it used the term Caro's Eröffnung (Caro's opening).[33] Kann died in 1886.[33] The joint name Caro-Kann appears in an article by Curt von Bardeleben from July 1890.[33] Published games that began with 1.e4 c6 go back to the 1840s.[33]
Lichess (GitHub): lichess-org/chess-openings (commit 65bb03f), retrieved 6 Oct 2026. Licence: CC0 1.0. Our use: Opening names and ECO codes, matched by position; the moves are replayed by our code.
Wikibooks: Chess Opening Theory/1. e4/1...c6, retrieved 19 Oct 2026. Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0. Our use: Facts only, in our own words; no text copied.
Modern Chess (IM Siegfried Baumegger, 2 Dec 2025): A Comprehensive Guide to the Caro-Kann Defense, retrieved 19 Oct 2026. Licence: Copyright Modern Chess (treated as all rights reserved). Our use: Ideas only, in our own words; no text copied.
Wikipedia: Caro–Kann Defence, retrieved 19 Oct 2026. Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0. Our use: Facts only, in our own words; no text copied.
Chess Opening Scores (this site): How it works: source, sample, filters, rating levels, margins, retrieved 19 Oct 2026. Licence: CC0 1.0 (Lichess open database; our numbers made from it are CC0 as well). Our use: Our own statistics, calculated by code from the 12-month sample at every build.
Modern Chess (IM Siegfried Baumegger, 2 Dec 2025): Caro-Kann Defense - Advance Variation, retrieved 19 Oct 2026. Licence: Copyright Modern Chess (treated as all rights reserved). Our use: Ideas only, in our own words; no text copied.
Modern Chess (IM Siegfried Baumegger, 2 Dec 2025): Caro-Kann Defense - Exchange Variation, retrieved 19 Oct 2026. Licence: Copyright Modern Chess (treated as all rights reserved). Our use: Ideas only, in our own words; no text copied.
Modern Chess (IM Siegfried Baumegger, 2 Dec 2025): Caro-Kann Defense - Panov Attack, retrieved 19 Oct 2026. Licence: Copyright Modern Chess (treated as all rights reserved). Our use: Ideas only, in our own words; no text copied.
Modern Chess (IM Siegfried Baumegger, 2 Dec 2025): Caro-Kann Defense - Classical System, retrieved 19 Oct 2026. Licence: Copyright Modern Chess (treated as all rights reserved). Our use: Ideas only, in our own words; no text copied.
python-chess (Niklas Fiekas): python-chess 1.11.2 (the move replay our build uses), retrieved 19 Oct 2026. Licence: GPL-3.0 library, used as a tool; nothing copied. Our use: Our build replays every line from the starting position and compares the positions.
Lichess (GitHub): lichess-org/chess-openings (commit 65bb03f), retrieved 24 Oct 2026. Licence: CC0 1.0. Our use: Opening names and ECO codes, matched by position; the moves are replayed by our code.
Wikipedia: Caro–Kann Defence, retrieved 24 Oct 2026. Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0. Our use: Facts only, in our own words; no text copied.
Modern Chess (IM Siegfried Baumegger, 2 Dec 2025): Caro-Kann Defense - Panov Attack, retrieved 24 Oct 2026. Licence: Copyright Modern Chess (treated as all rights reserved). Our use: Ideas only, in our own words; no text copied.
Lichess (GitHub): lichess-org/chess-openings (commit 65bb03f), retrieved 25 Oct 2026. Licence: CC0 1.0. Our use: Opening names and ECO codes, matched by position; the moves are replayed by our code.
Wikipedia: Caro–Kann Defence, retrieved 25 Oct 2026. Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0. Our use: Facts only, in our own words; no text copied.
Modern Chess (IM Siegfried Baumegger, 2 Dec 2025): A Comprehensive Guide to the Caro-Kann Defense, retrieved 25 Oct 2026. Licence: Copyright Modern Chess (treated as all rights reserved). Our use: Ideas only, in our own words; no text copied.
Lichess (GitHub): lichess-org/chess-openings (commit 65bb03f), retrieved 27 Oct 2026. Licence: CC0 1.0. Our use: Opening names and ECO codes, matched by position; the moves are replayed by our code.
Wikipedia: Caro–Kann Defence, retrieved 27 Oct 2026. Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0. Our use: Facts only, in our own words; no text copied.
Lichess (GitHub): lichess-org/chess-openings (commit 65bb03f), retrieved 29 Oct 2026. Licence: CC0 1.0. Our use: Opening names and ECO codes, matched by position; the moves are replayed by our code.
Wikipedia: Caro–Kann Defence, retrieved 29 Oct 2026. Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0. Our use: Facts only, in our own words; no text copied.
Lichess (GitHub): lichess-org/chess-openings (commit 65bb03f), retrieved 8 Nov 2026. Licence: CC0 1.0. Our use: Opening names and ECO codes, matched by position; the moves are replayed by our code.
Wikipedia: Caro–Kann Defence, retrieved 8 Nov 2026. Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0. Our use: Facts only, in our own words; no text copied.
Modern Chess (IM Siegfried Baumegger, 2 Dec 2025): Caro-Kann Defense - Two Knights System, retrieved 8 Nov 2026. Licence: Copyright Modern Chess (treated as all rights reserved). Our use: Ideas only, in our own words; no text copied.
Lichess (GitHub): lichess-org/chess-openings (commit 65bb03f), retrieved 10 Nov 2026. Licence: CC0 1.0. Our use: Opening names and ECO codes, matched by position; the moves are replayed by our code.
Wikipedia: Caro–Kann Defence, retrieved 11 Nov 2026. Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0. Our use: Facts only, in our own words; no text copied.
Edward Winter, Chess Notes (latest update 2 June 2026): The Caro-Kann Defence, retrieved 19 Oct 2026. Licence: Copyright Edward Winter (all rights reserved). Our use: Facts only, in our own words; no text copied.
Our sentences are our own wording. How the texts and numbers are made: Method.
Download these numbers: Caro-Kann Defense (CSV) (the rating-level, time-control and reply tables for 1.e4 c6 only; the wiki section's tables are not in it), released under CC0. For move-by-move exploration with your own filters, see the free Lichess opening explorer. This independent page lists each rating level and each time control in its own row for comparison.